Revisiting RazEr: Finally getting rid of those concrete wheels

Let’s return to a scooter which is not made of wood.

For the longest time, the only thing that’s prevented RazEr rEVolution from being an actual useful vehicle has been the rock-hard wheels I selected for some reason last year. Both were surplus finds and very cheap, and the rear wheel especially was selected at the time for its low tread profile. Being industrial casters, though, they were hard, a fact that I didn’t really think about being a possibility before I got them. The front wheel is 95A Durometer (pretty damn hard) and the rear wheel was 90D Durometer (might as well be plastic).

So basically every time I rode RazEr around, there was a loud rumbling sound on top of the earsplitting 4kHz PWM sound, and afterwards I could not feel my ankles. RazEr rides were limited to indoor, smooth environments. This isn’t to say I didn’t try riding it back and forth across campus a few times, but the numbness in my joints afterwards threatened early arthritis and I was constantly afraid of shaking apart the components inside the motor and destroying the melontroller. Ultimately, though, the vehicle prevailed over my willingness to ride it…until I accidentally detonated the controller in Singapore. With RazEr out of service anyway, I got a little more motivation to replace the wheels. The other portion of the motivation came from discovering how well Straight RazEr handled with the 5″ 65A durometer Colson Caster wheels (a staple of combat robotics in the past). Straight Razer rode very well as just a regular scooter, but it just had too much horsepower to safely handle day to day.

I never thought you could machine a Colson wheel all the way out to the tire, however. My impression of them was that the plastic ended very close to where the rubber began. Therefore, coring them out would not end well as the ring lost integrity while being machined. But while visiting the GT Invention Studio, I watched Colson wheels being machined for A Certain Other Hub Motor Scooter (no, not that one…. the other one). It was indeed possible -the Colsons had a plastic ribbing that the tire was molded over, so even the clamping pressure of a lathe chuck wasn’t enough to deform them for light and moderate cutting passes.

Well, could have had me fooled. It was time to change tires.

There was a problem, though. The 5″ Colson wheel can only be bored out to about 3.3 inches, and the Dual Non-Interleaved Razermotor had that big aluminum outer case which measured at 3.5 inches. This would have required alot of machining of rubber, which was suboptimal.

However, the original Razermotor V1 (dear god that’s an old post) had an outer can diameter of 3.25 inches, the maximum diameter a 125mm scooter wheel can be bored to. Its successor, Razermotor V2, had the same dimensions. Conveniently enough, a 5″ Colson can be bored to 3.25 inches with no issue. So the solution was to make a longer can version of Razermotor V2 to fit the existing stator of the DNIR.

This is a 5″ black Colson wheel. It is in fact the 100th build picture of RazEr rEVolution, continuing my streak of photographing utterly boring subjects for the centenary build picture. To bore this wheel out, I needed a lathe big enough to grip the entire outside of the tire.

Luckily, one existed in the form of a recent addition to the vehicle teams shop: a late model 19″ LeBlond Regal . This thing is the size of a car, and before I hopped on it to start messing around with the controls, I have in fact not seen it ever run. But run it does, and it’s probably now my favorite heavy metal mayhem machine on campus (no less because I have access to it 24/7 and it has all the nice features… minus a DRO). The installed chuck is a 10 inch type which opens wide enough to shove the whole Colson in.

Even more luckily, the only accessory it came with was a boring bar. There were other tool blocks to fit the toolpost, but I would have to “borrow” the tooling of the other machines to use them.

A few minutes later, a centerless Colson. The cores of these things are made of polypropylene, so they’re exceptionally easy to machine.

I ordered my usual Giant Steel Pipe from Speedy Metals to build the new rotor.

This is where the horsepower and mass of this thing really shined. By this time, I had already assembled some basic tooling, and was having fun making 3/8″ inch wide bright blue steel curls that were several feet long. Technically that’s a bad thing to come off a lathe during operation, but it’s a welcome change from the slightly anemic Old Mercedes (I haven’t thought of a snappy nickname for this one yet, but nothing short of Leviathan or Behemoth or Kraken or something would suffice).

I also spent a little while reading about how the Servo Shift worked. This was LeBlond’s “thing”, and it was pretty much an automatic transmission for a lathe driven by hydraulic cylinders and controlled by electrically actuated valves with switches as feedback (Turning the big dial selects which set of switches the gears have to move in place to trigger). The spindle literally jiggles back and forth while the shift is occurring (in a manual transmission lathe, you jiggle the spindle yourself to mesh the gears together). This machine completes the cycle in a second or two, which apparently means the Servo Shift is working exceptionally well – it sounds like an utter pain in the ass if it ever breaks.

I love overly complex mechanical solutions to a simple problem. The rest of the variable-speed machines here use belt-based CVTs, which are far less parts but less heavy metal.

Okay, enough diddling. Time to make a motor can.

The protoform can emerges. This is actually the second attempt. On try number 1, I was still getting used to where the threading controls were and how they functioned specifically to the machine, so after almost finishing the part I accidentally started the carriage incorrectly and instantly plowed off all of my threads.

D’oh.

The thread is a 3.25″-24, which is not in any standard catalog of threaded objects. It just means I have to make my own matching nut again.

I borrowed a Nice Carbide Threading Tool from the Edgerton Center Student Shop, and its niceness shows. These were cleaned up a bit with a pass of Scotch Brite.

Unfortunately, hugelathe didn’t have a parting tool yet, and other tools couldn’t be used on it again because of toolpost incompatibility. I therefore had to transfer the part over to another machine to perform the cutoff. In this case, it’s the second largest machine in the shop, a Clausing 4900 type.

After the cutoff was complete, I transferred it back in order to finish the stepped bore for the endcaps. Tossing a part between machines like this is risky for concentricity unless the workholding implements are exceptionally well-made and precise. The old American machinery did not disappoint.

The finished product.

The next day, I returned to remake the endcaps. These now mount directly inside the steel rotor, so they’re smaller in diameter.

I finally took apart the DNIR to recover the stator and center shaft. I’m glad to see that even after being stuffed into a rock tumbler posing as a wheel, the stator, windings, and sensors are all intact. However, the winding potting epoxy, which I used a cellulose filler (read: paper fluff) for, seems to have charred from the heat. That was quite interesting to see – at first I thought the windings were burnt, but it’s just the paper fluff not handling high temperatures very well.

With the “protoform” can and endcaps done, it was time to drill the radial mounting holes using my trusty indexing fixture.

I still have to glue the magnets inside the new can, but after that, I should be able to just put everything back together and have it work. This takes care of the back wheel of RazEr – the front wheel is less of a priority, but given that I have another Colson, I will probably go ahead and finish that too.

Oh, yeah, and fix the controller. Hmm, this might take longer than anticipated…

The Post-Everything Update, Part II: Maker Faire(s)

I’m back in the zone.

After back-hauling 1185 miles over 2 days from Atlanta to Cambridge, Assachusetts (and discovering in the process that Budget Rent-a-Car’s computer system cannot comprehend a mileage with 4 figures, to my delight), I’m about to go back down about 20% of the way…to the NY World Maker Faire as part of the MITERS booth/table display.

Great… maybe I should have just stayed a few extra days and just went 80% of that distance instead.

The reason why I ended up bringing most of everything ever (i.e. more than just the robots for Dragon*Con)  down to Atlanta in the first place was because of Maker Faire practice.

The Atlanta Mini Maker Faire, hosted by Georgia Tech, was a week after the D*C robot event, so I elected to knock a week off the semester and show up after being invited by some of the GT Invention Studio folks.

The event was held in a not-too-large parking lot, and about 60 individual exhibitors were there. The above picture is of the crowd and a pretty nice electric Chevy S-10 pickup truck conversion.

With rideable objects now making up a majority of my project fleet, the event was a great chance to make sure all of them had some testing time without me in the loop. You are generally always careful and mindful of a vehicle’s limitations if you’re the builder, but no such luxuries are afforded when your vehicle is being tested by strangers who had about 30 seconds of instruction beforehand. I suppose a hallmark of a well-engineered vehicle is if anyone can operate it with 30 seconds of instruction and not have it explode.

Sadly, only about half of my “travel fleet” made it through the day.

Straight RazEr

As the previous test video showed, Straight RazEr did fairly well confusing GT students on campus. After raising the front ground clearance another inch, it could finally turn and go over the average sidewalk crack and things like that. I brought it to the MMF, and it performed admirably well throwing off several random people.

The trick with sensorless brushless scooters is that you cannot just stand on it and hit the throttle. At least, don’t do it multiple times, since the motor pulling stall current across the controller will heat it up quickly. While most everyone understood the lecture and handled this part fine, I’m fairly certain the one person who didn’t caused the demise of Straight RazEr. A few seconds after I handed it off, I heard cries of “smoke!” and “fire!!” from the crowd behind me. I turned around and without much reaction, watched the massive plume of Turnigy smoke billowing out of Straight RazEr’s upper rear deck.

The short-circuit current desoldered my Deans main power connector. Some of the smoke and “Turnigy splatter” looks like it also made it out of the power access holes.

That SR ended up exploding wasn’t really surprising – the fact that sensorless vehicles need to be “push started” is really an alien concept to most people unfamiliar with them, and the majority push off too slowly or weakly anyway. The same reason is why very few people can actually ride melon-scooter, which also has a much slower “pickup speed” than Straight RazEr due to the latter’s much wider gearing.

Oh well.

Because Straight Razer was built mostly as a troll and the controller can be replaced later, I’m not going to try to bring it to NY Maker Faire. It’s considered out of commission until further notice. I might try throwing a melontroller on it some time later, but that involves adding sensors to the motor.

Speaking of melontroller…

RazEr rEVolution

I don’t have pictures of RazEr at the event (it looks the same, trust me), but I’m definitely amazed at how well it has stood up. Not only was it extensively used to the point of battery depletion at the end, but both the motor and Melontroller 2.0 have survived what amounts to a continuous +/- 50g minimum shock test. Because of the very hard wheels I chose by mistake and ended up designing around (90D and 90A hardness for the rear and front!), every little sidewalk or road feature was transmitted without damping into the drivetrain. After the day of demos, I rode it twice around GT’s Yellow Jacket Park square essentially full throttle the whole time. Overall, RazEr’s design has proven itself to be very robust. I’m particularly relieved that Melontroller 2.0 is a stable version from which I can improve (you know, adding things like a real logic power regulator), so this is one goal for this fall and winter.

With Jamison’s new hub motor scooter sporting 60A Colson wheels, I’m also going to remake the front and rear wheels to use them. Maybe RazEr can actually be a useful vehicle after that.

However, for the time being, RazEr will be at NY Maker Faire, completely unchanged except for a full charge.

Segfault

The biggest and most awkwardly shaped member of the travel fleet, Segfault was already flaky before I left, and it only got worse at the event. Not only is the controller, originally designed to last maybe a week, now entering its 10th month of use, but the drive motors are slowly giving out too. The left Banebots P80 gearmox lost an internal shaft retaining ring some time ago, which means occasionally the left wheel just completely disengages and spins freely. I’d keep the thing running by literally just kicking or hammering the wheel back in. But finally, at the MMF, this happened.

Alright, I’m finished. Before this, the controller had pretty much been totally reduced to a ball of twitching and noise. The breadboards are slowly falling apart (their contacts falling out the bottom side after the glued-on paper backing expired) and most likely the contacts are also oxidizing and being sporadic. With all of this, Segfault is officially decommissioned and the current version will not be repaired or upgraded. I will probably part it back out and repair the left P80 motor for future projects. The vehicle is too big and unwieldy, and has more than served its purpose of control theory demos, so if I end up building another Segway-vehicle (ahem) it will be much smaller and lighter.

In the mean time, anyone want a full aluminum Segway-like vehicle frame? Just add your own P80 motors and Arduinos.

Because of the state of utter wreckage it’s in, Segfault is of course not coming to NYMF.

Land-bear-shark

This thing was a huge hit, and I’m proud to say that it also survived the day unscathed (though with quite a few more stickers). It looks very squat and unimposing, but few people could actually stay on and ride it because of how high off the ground the rider stands and the short “wheelbase”. The Beast-it-trollers handled the whole day’s operation in 90-95 degree weather with no problems after I upgraded the drive FETs to IRFB3207 4 milliohm parts, instead of the old IRF1407s which flamed out two Swapfests ago.

While the Advanced Beast-it-Troller has been assembled and bench-tested, I have not installed them or written the software for them… nor do I intend to for this weekend. LBS will be traveling to NYMF too, and I’ll probably be tooling around on it all day since it has about 25 amp-hours of battery onboard, and NYMF is half parking lot and half rolling grassy fields and gravel lots. Hell yes.

Other things that are also coming

I’m going to bring Überclocker and Cold Arbor along as display sculptures. Clocker is functional (not very battleworthy, but things do move) so it may participate in some demos.

The Kitmotor Demo Stand will probably be spinning on the table all day so more of you people will go and build scooters.

Finally, I’ll also truck along the erstwhile Make-a-Bot, which has been making parts for all the other projects almost trouble-free since last December. It’s now a generation and some behind the kit 3d printer features curve, and I intend to rebuild it in the near future. Maybe I’ll park it in the 3d printer nest, next to all the Makerbots to troll Bre Pettis. After all, it’s about 75% faster than a stock Thing-o-matic and 1000% more \m/etal.