The Overhaul 2 Design & Build Series, Part 10: What Do You Mean It’s Out of Stock?

Monday, June 20th, 2016 @ 1:20 | BattleBots 2016, Bots, Overhaul 2

Previously, on How to Build an Overhaul…

dramatic over the shoulder camera angle here

charles stares intently at a lathe on autofeed

 -
CHARLES
-

“this insert seems a little dull and i want some mountain dew”

Machining the parts for the lift clutch was well under way by early March, and parts were coming in almost daily. Our goal was still to have “the robot minus the frame” done by the 3rd week of March, when the CNC machined frame was to arrive. For instance, here are infinite wheels:

After confirming that one hub works, it was time to make all of them. Now, these Colson wheels are made of polypropylene with overmolded rubber. The plastic is so soft that it would rather mush around than be cut, unless it had no other choice. Broaching the wheels made all kinds of neat Colson art, like so…

The next step to assemble all the drive wheels was to chamfer the tips of the waterjet-cut sprockets. Chamfering the tips makes the sprocket more tolerant to side-to-side chain slop since the teeth become narrower, and so the chain has more wiggle room before it tries to catch between teeth and fall off. And I can think of no better application where your chain is likely to have a sudden amount of side to side slop!

There were 30-something sprockets to machine, and I needed a solution to make life simple.

Enter MarkForged

I designed a jig that the sprockets bolted into – they had the correct center bore and two keyways to drive the sprockets, and were made using several layers of Kevlar reinforcement for strength (This wasn’t a critical application that had to be Kevlar – it was honestly what I just had loaded in the machine at the time. Any of their fibers would have been as rigid, or more rigid). On the inside of this print was a hex socket that fit a 1/2″-20 nut. A 1/2″-20 bolt runs through the body, giving it even more rigidity, as well as retaining the sprocket. It was then easy to chuck the jig into a lathe, holding the sprocket away from the chuck, and quickly chamfer both sides with a cutter. Then simply swap the sprocket out and continue!

The other piece shown is a portion of the electrical deck. It holds the robot-side main battery connector onto the electrical box, and was included with this print because why not. I wanted to try out the dimensions in real life to see if any adjustments had to be made.

After broaching the 5″ and 3″ colsons, I began to become concerned about how easy the wheels were to broach.  While the 5″ Colsons had plenty of material at the hub, the smaller 3″ ones had a significant portion of the hub’s radial thickness removed when I broached them. This was concerning, because the reduced material ring beyond the keyway, coupled with the sharp keyway edges, and the fact that the front wheels would be under the most stress when lifting an opponent, meant that the wheel was likely to crack apart.

Not cool. So one of the first “dynamic redesigns” of this build is now needed – the front wheels. I decided to design a MarkForged printable hub, to which a polyurethane tire is bonded.

The 3″ Colson wheel also only covers about half the hub width, as smaller sizes don’t come in the 2″ wide size. The new front wheel would be equally wide as the rest.

The outer ridges are to increase the surface area available for the eventual glue bond.

Here are some “cheat code” features to optimize the part for a MarkForged machine. Right now (as of 6/2016), their slicing software doesn’t yet allow you to prioritize “internal” features, such as holes or bores. All fiber lay is from the outermost perimeter inwards. The reasons for this are many (including feature recognition challenges), but bottom line is, I can’t tell the slicer to fiber up the keyed bore itself.

So in a manner similar to the “hairline split holes” method of 3d printing parts with more perimeters, I added a few Slots of Persuasion to forcefully route the fiber layers into the places where I need it – the keyway area. The fibers will handle the majority of the power transmission stress, so I was less worried about the plastic necking down here.

I also could have made the wheel a “C” shape, with the ends of the C so close together as to be almost touching – and in real life, the plastic would bond together anyhow – but I wanted to avoid having a single linear weak spot in an otherwise complete structural loop. So, little guidance slits won out here.

I then added a few Holes of Persuasion to force some fiber layers towards the outside layer, and some towards the inside of the hub surface.

Here is a finished wheel! See the keyway being surrounded by fiber, as are the inner and outer surfaces for the most part. I could have put Kevlar into all the layers, but decided to be a bit more economical. Each wheel contains just barely under half a spool of Kevlar. The rest of the volume is simply densely filled.

I’ll be the first to admit that I am not a master of composites and adhesives. I used whatever glue McMaster called “urethane glue”, part number 7493A21. My criterion for selecting this adhesive was “Says Urethane on it, does not require an expensive-ass dispensing gun or carefully pushing out with a stick, and comes in the little cute bubble packet”. This is roughly the same process used to select a bearing grease for Mikuvan’s front wheel bearings (“Well, it has a picture of a car on it”) and those haven’t blown up on me…. yet.

Help me.

The tire material is a soft urethane tube, McMaster part number 87235K74. I cut rings off the long tube I purchased, 2″ wide to accommodate the hubs. It gets stretched over the hub after the hub is throughly coated in the urethane OH GOD IT DOESN’T COME OFF AND IT’S STUCK TO EVERYTHING adhesive. I wiggle the tire on and use the dribbles to fill gaps and create edge fillets. Then I leave the wheels alone for a day or two.

The evening I put these together shall forever be remembered as Urethanocalypse 2016.

Here’s a pile of infinite finished wheels! Well, semi-infinite. We decided that a 100% set of spares was sufficient to start. In the event of post-match damage, swap the wheel for a known good one right away, then deal with the repairs after

Next up, infinite spider couplings. Notice how there’s a lot of “infinite” on this bot? Again, a manifestation of the design goal that is making all of the spare parts in one shot, with the parts themselves designed to be easily replicable. Other builders prefer building 1.0 robots first, then working on spare parts.

All of the spider couplings are broached for 1/8″ keyways to slide directly on the lift motors.

And finally, we get to….

Infinite SK3 motors.

This is where I introduce Equals Zero Robotics’ 2nd sponsor for the 2016 BattleBots season…

HOBBYKING!

Yes, that HobbyKing, a familiar sight on this website for many years!  I was in talks with them as early as Sadbot running on the dlux 250 hacks. Originally, it was just for more dlux 250 units, but I decided to go deeper. The robot community has a love-hate-love-again relationship with HobbyKing’s legendary Chinesium offerings, and many smaller bots have used HK parts to great effect. But can they play bigger?

Either way, some great exposure potential for HK, so they agreed to send goodies my way. One of these shipments was a nontrivial percentage of the world’s supply of SK3-6374-192 motors.

Another shipment was more running gear for the bot:

 

Critical subssystems and support equipment, all sponsored by HobbyKing.

Overhaul 2 will be running the 9XR Pro radio system with the long-range 433mhz R/C gear, to get me off the 2.4Ghz band. I wanted out of 2.4Ghz entirely – everything from other robots, to WiFi, to production running wireless lighting and microphones and the like, lives in 2.4Ghz. Last year, a few people had control difficulties (including yours truly) in the box, and I was not out to repeat that.

Next up are battery chargers and charger power supplies, as well as some BEC units to run the logic power (receivers, gaudy lighting, etc.) since the ESCs do not provide 5v power. Speaking of ESCs…

What’s missing is a boatload of DLUX 250 controllers.

Let’s rewind a few weeks here. What happened was that I compiled a bill of materials to send to Hobbyking, which included 12 dlux 250 controllers. Everything on the list was packed up and shipped to me, except the DLUX 250s, because…

I’ve gotten confirmation from the manager that this product has been completely discontinued and the factories are no longer making them.

Oh, snap.

After some highly intense back-and-forth over e-mail about possible replacements, I decided to spring for swapping the 250A model for the 160A model.

This was a very stressful decision. R/C amps are usually 0.2 to 0.5 of a real amp* and I was getting concerned about the real ampacity of these controllers. While I had familiarity with them from the BurnoutChibi project, the lack of large-package FETs (in favor of a sprinkling of small surface-mount FETs) and smaller thermal mass was the clincher. I also didn’t have a handle on their reliability – the only DLUX 250A units I’ve ever killed were due to my own stupidity, such as hard shorting outputs or leaving the bus capacitors off.

It was therefore imperative I get units in hand as soon as possible, as even the stock quantity of DLUX 160s was getting low (less than 15 remaining around the world in stock, as I recall). I really need to hand it to Hobbyking here for trying to round up stock in such short order.

*this statement is not backed by any form of science but is pretty accurate

The DLUX 160A controllers came a few days after the rest of the shipment. I immediate got cracking on tearing them open to see what I had to change for in the SimonK firmware. Luckily, the answer was not much. I had to redefine a few resistor values, and also set a correct deadtime (these switched slightly faster due to the smaller FET packages), but otherwise, they were the same pinout and layout. Go figure, but just to make sure.

I then uparmored them like I would the DLUX 250A, but these only had space for one big ol’ capacitor, which is better than nothing!

A set of three DLUX 160A controllers fully modded up. I was going to whip these things in Sadbot to ensure they don’t explode.

I removed the 250A controllers from Sadbot – now a valuable and rare commodity – and tied these guys in, then proceeded to drive around like a maniac, just like I did with the 250A, and lift & self right and do other things with the pokey stick.

Here’s a test video showing a little bit of it. The open floor tests were to try and stress the controller with many reversing and turning instances, and the sliding was induced by keeping the wheels spinning (drawing wheelspin current) as much as possible.

(RIP Frozen fans and normal people)

The controllers passed this test solidly, I’d say. I was beginning to smell SK3 windings before the controllers became too hot to touch, so that’s a good thing.

However, while powering up Sadbot for another test a few days later…

A minor smoke event occurred.

One issue with R/C controllers, especially large ones, is that they scale beyond their hardware designs that were originally put together for small ones. Without proper gate drive, and with the possibility of mixed parts in the power stage, if one FET blows up, it tends to start taking the rest with it. And some times, this happens almost spuriously. This is how a controller works for someone and not for the next person. Add to that the quality control generally associated with hobby parts, and….

Okay, let’s be clear: THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A MINOR DLUX SMOKE EVENT. The whole thing is seemingly made of thermite, or the mix of materials acts as a rapid propellant, because it was over in 5 seconds, a foot of flame, and a huge plume of smoke. I was in fact fearful of a lithium fire with the batteries next to it, and was getting ready to shove the whole thing off the loading dock. The polycarbonate battery box from Overhaul 1 protected the batteries, luckily.

This was all that remained…. As you can see, the entire PCB is actually burnt in half.

By this time, I didn’t want to try to investigate yet another controller. And unless I were willing to pop out Brushless Rage™ in three weeks and get it right the first time, this is what I was going to have to deal with, and part of what I committed myself to doing – using big R/C parts in big robots – from the very start.

So it was time to put the controllers down and keep moving. I asked Hobbyking for a large stockpile of the 160A units to be laundered my way ASAP. I decided to formulate an electrical system continuity solution which used the DLUX 250As remaining (5) as much as possible, and substituting in the 160s if absolutely needed, but ensuring that I had a full bot set of DLUX 160A controllers right away.

While I was doing these tests, the others had finished machining the motor mounting blocks for the SK3s, and keying the shafts.

Ah, finally, all my ducks in a row!

The difference between a “left” motor and “right” motor is simply which direction the wire leads come out, to keep the wiring in the bot convenient.

 

The next step was to assemble all the gearboxes. Four left, four right, and four lift motors were to be assembled. Again, a 100% overhead (hehehe, overhead for Overhaul) such that we could pitch in a spare set right away and mull over the broken ones in the pits later.

Notice the delicious strawberry jelly on the left. Mmm, extreme-pressure additives.

Here’s a fully assembled drive motor, with retaining bracket!

Repeat like 20 billion times

Okay, so I lied about getting away from controllers, again!

Overhaul 2 still has that 1 brushed motor onboard, the A23-150 micro-Ampflow motor to run the clamping arm. To use this motor, I needed a high voltage (12S capable) DC motor controller.

Now, I had designed a 8S-capable motor controller of some type a little while ago, and in fact, one of the original RageBridge 2 plans was to have it be 12S-capable. But I decided to scale back for expense and usability reasons – most everyone runs these at 6S (around 24v) or in extreme, unsupported-by-manufacturer (AHEM, WILL BALES) cases, 10S (36-42v).

To change Rage over to the higher voltage specification was actually an intensive job, basically rebuilding the board. The main capacitors were changed to 50V types, the MOSFETs to 60v parts, and a lot of other little things moved along with them – such as changing the gate resistors to accommodate the new drive needs, and the logic regulator to a HV-rated part.

In the end, I whipped together two HVRage™ units for the clamp motor, and tested them (see the small blue wires used as scoping points) to ensure nothing was going to get TOO fiery.

And this is the conclusion of Overhaul 2: Actual Electric Boogaloo (sorry Orion). Next up? A Series of Tubes:

Side note: Overhaul 2 swag is now up on the BattleBots store, if you haven’t seen yet. All artwork by Cynthia! Proceeds of sales do go to the builders, so you’d be sponsoring supportng Overhaul for #season3!

 

 

Recently

  • Operation RESTORING BROWN Episode VI: Return of the Van Lights; the Conclusion
  • Late Stage #PostmodernRobotics: Welcome to Your Waifu is Trash, the Robot Dumpster Fire
  • Operation RESTORING BROWN 5: The Road to Reassembly
  • Operation RESTORING BROWN: The Paintening
  • Operation RESTORING BROWN Part III: An Electric Interlude
  • Operation RESTORING BROWN: Romance of the Rusty Roof Rail Repair
  • Operation: RESTORING BROWN: Vivisection of the Beast – the Summer of vantruck Begins;
  • Beyond Unboxing: Inside a Very Chinesium Mini MIG Welder
  • The Most Curious Story of Sadvan
  • How to Remedy Your Mitsubishi Delica’s Leaking Windshield: A Pictorial Guide; Or, Van Facility Improvements Late 2018 to Nowish
  •  

    2 Responses to “The Overhaul 2 Design & Build Series, Part 10: What Do You Mean It’s Out of Stock?”

    1. Peter Says:

      You have successfully done what few ever have, voluntarily and enthusiastically watch network TV!

      I did sneak away during the commercials back to the milling machine, but was otherwise glued to the program.

      I am very excited to see how you do in the completion, and thanks for the great posts on the design and built of this years machine.

    2. tician Says:

      Yeah, Hobbyking has one of the shittiest inventory systems I’ve ever encountered. A certain 16AWG wire (915000010-0) has been completely out of stock from USA East since at least the big sale around 4/19. Had it canceled off of first order and the CS rep got the site fixed to correctly identify it as out of stock, then made a second order when it showed up as 10+ in stock again a week later. Waited a month on that second order with the site saying it is 10+ in stock almost the entire time and the site is still saying it is 10+ in stock three weeks after finally canceling that part of the second order.

      Interestingly, the hobbyking website currently lists the dlux 250 HV as 6 in stock from the International Warehouse. Yet another failure of their inventory system?