The Forthcoming RageBridge: Stick Calibration

Saturday, February 2nd, 2013 @ 8:06 | Bots, Motor Controllers, Project Build Reports, Reference Posts

They’re here!

All of the RageBridges! All of them ever!

Or rather, 100 of them, in neatly packaged panels of two. Here’s what one of the manufactured panels looks like.

Pretty cool.

Okay, so these actually got in last week, but I’ve been doing some background and infrastructural work since then. I’m planning on gathering a few friends and flashing, populating headers, and testing all of these this coming weekend. I decided to leave the chips unflashed because I was not yet satisfied with the firmware (and the flashing was a few hundred extra dollars), and the headers are purposefully left unpopulated because many people prefer soldered-on pigtails or their own wiring configuration. It’s definitely a little more legwork on our end, but for such a small run (100, maybe with a few duds) I think it’s still manageable, and will allow the fine settling into best practices that inevitably accompany any parts business. Time to be a little adventurous.

From a firmware perspective, the only thing RageBridge has been missing since the last board revision is a way to calibrate the servo PWM range. This is generally preferred because not all radios are created equally, and some may have more stick travel & adjustable PWM endpoints than others. For instance, my (nice for 2006) Spektrum radio can hit the full 1000-2000uS servo range if I navigate through the menus and tell it to stretch its range a bit. But my cheesy Hobbyking 6 channel radios can’t do the same unless connected to a computer to program them – the stock range is more like 1200 to 1800us. So, any fixed input range will inevitably be a compromise – for some people, the stock settings will be too twitchy (i.e. stick travel range is greater than the board’s accepted input range), or you might not ever hit full throttle (because the radio stick travel doesn’t go far enough to match the controller input range).

Calibration has always been one of those things that I accepted as working, but never thought about implementing. Depending on how it’s done, it can be relatively simple, or a mess of state machine code.

One of the most common modern calibration paradigms is the “stick-high” method, used by most R/C model controllers, whether air, sea, or ground. This involves powering on the controller with a receiver attached (and generally, already powered and outputting valid pulsewidths) and you commanding full positive travel. If the first thing that the ESC sees, or sees within 1-2 seconds, is a full positive signal, then it waits for a few seconds and checks again. If you are still holding full positive, then it beeps or blinks (accepting the full positive position), and then you back off to full negative and hold for a few seconds, then back to neutral. For single channel ESCs without many other features, it’s pretty much the way to go.

I decided to implement stick-high calibration for RB, except modifying it for both channels at once. This entailed adding a timed loop in the middle where normally you would just check for full positive and full negative signals. The idea is that during the timed loop, the user just swirls the sticks around all at once and the controller will capture both ranges simultaneously. At any point, if the signal returns to neutral for more than 2 seconds, the calibration routine exits and writes the results to EEPROM so it is persistent.

Of course, there’s other little touches to make the system more robust like checking for pulse validity (rejecting malformed or misread pulses) and fail-safe performance if the user bails out in the middle. In all, it took me a few hours of planning and a few hours of beasting Arduino code, and I’m quite pleased with the final result.

So, in a completely out of context brain bump, here’s RageBridge’s stick calibration code. When I ship it through, the full source code will be released along with board files, but I’m putting this early because I’m particularly proud of it.

I subscribe to the Expository Essay school of code commenting – I literally write what every line and every procedure does, in detail, and in natural english. To hardcore and experienced coders this might seem like a waste of characters, but I find it particularly easy to read my way back through old code and decipher what the hell I thought I was doing when I wrote it. So there’s actually plenty of paragraphs in the comments.

As a bit of backstory since I didn’t post all the variable definitions, anything with a _1 or _2 is referring to the channel of RB it is relevant to. The code is written with Arduino 1.0.1 using the PinChangeInt and EEPROM libraries (PCI is not used in this section as the interrupt procedures that capture servo pulsewidths are not shown).

  • RCMAX, et. al. are all declared as signed integers at the beginning of the code (not shown).
  • CALIBRATION_CONSTANT is a fraction of the total stick travel, right now 0.66. In other words, anything ABOVE 66% of the current maximum travel is grounds for entering calibration mode. This is one of the tricks I added to prevent calibrating yourself out of your own radio travel bounds. So, basically what it entails is each time you calibrate you could reduce the range by 1/3rd if you had to.
  • neutral_counter and NEUTRAL_CYCLES_MAX refer to how many iterations of the neutral signal checking routine can run before the calibration procedure is declared to be done.
  • NEUTRAL_DELTA is the pulse width deviation around the current neutral point that can be recognized as a new valid neutral point. For instance, the default neutral pulsewidth for servo PWM is 1500us. If NEUTRAL_DELTA is defined as 100, which it is, then anything from 1400 to 1600 may be set as a new neutral point. This is to make sure you cannot drift the center stick zero throttle point too far, even on purpose. You can, of course, do so by running multiple calibration cycles. But why!?
  //Collect the user calibration endpoints from EEPROM. If the EEPROM values return 255
  //then calibration has never occurred, so use defaults.
  RCMAX_1 = (signed int);
  RCMAX_1 += (signed int)( << 8);
  RCMIN_1 = (signed int);
  RCMIN_1 += (signed int)( << 8);
  RCCENTER_1 = (signed int);
  RCCENTER_1 += (signed int)( << 8);
  RCMAX_2 = (signed int);
  RCMAX_2 += (signed int)( << 8);
  RCMIN_2 = (signed int);
  RCMIN_2 += (signed int)( << 8);
  RCCENTER_2 = (signed int);
  RCCENTER_2 += (signed int)( << 8);

  //Bytes will return 255 if they were never read; full 16 bit result is 65535
  if(RCMAX_1 == 0xffff ) {
  if(RCMIN_1 == 0xffff) {
  if(RCCENTER_1 == 0xffff) {
  if(RCMAX_2 == 0xffff) {
  if(RCMIN_2 == 0xffff ) {
  if(RCCENTER_2 == 0xffff) {

  delay(1000); //Just chill for a bit to make sure radios have bound and begun sending out good signal.

  //Calibration mode procedure.
  //After initialization, check for good signal on channels 1 and 2
  //If the signal is above the calibration threshold on both channels, keep waiting. If not, enter main program loop.
  //If at the end of 5 seconds the stick has been held, enter calibration mode. If it has not, enter main program loop.
  //Even if there is no good signal, proceed to main loop anyway - the main loop begins in failsafe mode. 
  if(is_pulse_good(vol_ch1_pw,RC_ABS_MAX,RC_ABS_MIN) && is_pulse_good(vol_ch2_pw,RC_ABS_MAX,RC_ABS_MIN)) {
    signed int init_calib_threshold_1 = (signed int)(CALIBRATION_CONSTANT*(RCMAX_1-RCCENTER_1))+RCCENTER_1;
    signed int init_calib_threshold_2 = (signed int)(CALIBRATION_CONSTANT*(RCMAX_2-RCCENTER_2))+RCCENTER_2;

    if(vol_ch1_pw > init_calib_threshold_1 && vol_ch2_pw > init_calib_threshold_2) {

      //To check for stick hold, begin the timer and set a flag that will be cleared if the stick is released
      unsigned long calibration_timer = millis();
      boolean entered_calibration = true;

      //Enter 5 second wait loop, constantly checking for stick release. Invalid signal also constitutes "stick release".
      while(millis() - calibration_timer < 5000) {
        if(is_pulse_good(vol_ch1_pw,RC_ABS_MAX,RC_ABS_MIN) && is_pulse_good(vol_ch2_pw,RC_ABS_MAX,RC_ABS_MIN)) {
          if(vol_ch1_pw < init_calib_threshold_1 || vol_ch2_pw < init_calib_threshold_2) {
            entered_calibration = false;
          } //End stick release check
        } else {
          entered_calibration = false;
        } //End pulse good check

      } //End wait for 5 seconds to check for stick hold

      //If the flag is still true, then the user has held the stick for > 5 seconds above the threshold
      //Calibration mode description:
      //Resetting the old max and min bounds to a lower threshold (CALIBRATION_CONSTANT * RCMAX_n)
      //If a newly captured value exceeds the thresholds, save it. 
      //If a newly captured value is within a certain % of neutral (NEUTRAL_CONSTANT * RCCENTER_n above or below RCCENTER), start a timer
      //After 3 seconds of this, assume the user has returned stick to desired neutral and take several samples for neutral position
      //If any pulse is invalid, bail out of calibration and retain old values.
      if(entered_calibration) { 

        digitalWrite(BLINK_FURIOUSLY,HIGH); //Set the LED on solid to let the user know that calibration has begun

        //Set initial thresholds to exceed. The thresholds are a certain % of the current set of maxes and mins
        //such that the controller can never be "calibrated out". By only exceeding the threshold very slightly
        //subsequent iterations of calibration can narrow the range of signals too, if it is necessary.
        signed int rcmax_1_temp = (signed int)(CALIBRATION_CONSTANT*(RCMAX_1-RCCENTER_1)) + RCCENTER_1;
        signed int rcmin_1_temp = RCCENTER_1 - (signed int)(CALIBRATION_CONSTANT*(RCCENTER_1-RCMIN_1));
        signed int rcmax_2_temp = (signed int)(CALIBRATION_CONSTANT*(RCMAX_2-RCCENTER_2)) + RCCENTER_2;
        signed int rcmin_2_temp = RCCENTER_2 - (signed int)(CALIBRATION_CONSTANT*(RCCENTER_2-RCMIN_2));
        signed int rccenter_1_temp = RCCENTER_1;
        signed int rccenter_2_temp = RCCENTER_2;

        boolean am_calibrating = true;
        boolean commit_calibration = false;

        byte neutral_counter = 0;

        //Set the main calibration loop going. 
        //First, check for good pulses. If any are bad, the routine is immediately ended and changes are NOT saved.
        //Next, check for pulses near neutral. If any are, increment a counter. If the counter is over a threshold,
        //then the user has returned the stick to netural and calibratoin can exit/changes be saved.
        //If any subsequent pulses are outside of the neutral bound, zero the counter. 
        //Next, expand the pulse range if the new set of pulsewidths are greater in magnitude deviation
        while(am_calibrating) {

          //Sanity check - if any pulses are out of range or invalid, exit.
          if(is_pulse_good(vol_ch1_pw,RC_ABS_MAX,RC_ABS_MIN) && is_pulse_good(vol_ch2_pw,RC_ABS_MAX,RC_ABS_MIN)) {

            //Save a copy of the current "volatile" pulsewidths (which can change randomly due to the interrupt)
            ch1_pw = vol_ch1_pw;
            ch2_pw = vol_ch2_pw;

            //Neutral check. If the signal is within the box of valid neutrals for enough cycles, exit and save changes.
            if(ch1_pw < (RCCENTER_1 + NEUTRAL_DELTA) && ch2_pw < (RCCENTER_2 + NEUTRAL_DELTA)) {
              if(ch1_pw > (RCCENTER_1 - NEUTRAL_DELTA) && ch2_pw > (RCCENTER_2 - NEUTRAL_DELTA)) {
                if(neutral_counter > NEUTRAL_CYCLES_MAX) {
                  am_calibrating = false;
                  commit_calibration = true;

                } else {
                  neutral_counter++; //Within bounds, but not exceeding number of allowed cycles, so increment and move on.
                  rccenter_1_temp = ch1_pw;
                  rccenter_2_temp = ch2_pw;
              } else {
                neutral_counter = 0; //If any of the within-bounds checks fails, reset the counter since the stick has moved.
            } //End neutral check

            //Bounds check; If the new pulses exceeds the current set of temporary calibration bounds in either direction
            //set them as the new bounds.
            if(ch1_pw > rcmax_1_temp) rcmax_1_temp = ch1_pw; else if(ch1_pw < rcmin_1_temp) rcmin_1_temp = ch1_pw;
            if(ch2_pw > rcmax_2_temp) rcmax_2_temp = ch2_pw; else if(ch2_pw < rcmin_2_temp) rcmin_2_temp = ch2_pw;
          } else {
            am_calibrating = false;
            commit_calibration = false; //Something has gone wrong and caused the calibration loop to terminate early...
          } //End sanity check
        } //End main calibration loop

        //Save changes?
        if(commit_calibration) {

          //First, reassign the constants for this power cycle...
          RCMAX_1 = rcmax_1_temp;
          RCMIN_1 = rcmin_1_temp;
          RCCENTER_1 = rccenter_1_temp;
          RCMAX_2 = rcmax_2_temp;
          RCMIN_2 = rcmin_2_temp;
          RCCENTER_2 = rccenter_2_temp;

          //Next, write these new values to EEPROM!
          byte rcmax_1_lowbyte = (RCMAX_1 & 0x00ff);
          byte rcmax_1_highbyte = ((RCMAX_1 >> 8) & 0x00ff);

          byte rcmin_1_lowbyte = (RCMIN_1 & 0x00ff);
          byte rcmin_1_highbyte = ((RCMIN_1 >> 8) & 0x00ff);

          byte rccenter_1_lowbyte = (RCCENTER_1 & 0x00ff);
          byte rccenter_1_highbyte = ((RCCENTER_1 >> 8) & 0x00ff);

          byte rcmax_2_lowbyte = (RCMAX_2 & 0x00ff);
          byte rcmax_2_highbyte = ((RCMAX_2 >> 8) & 0x00ff);

          byte rcmin_2_lowbyte = (RCMIN_2 & 0x00ff);
          byte rcmin_2_highbyte = ((RCMIN_2 >> 8) & 0x00ff);

          byte rccenter_2_lowbyte = (RCCENTER_2 & 0x00ff);
          byte rccenter_2_highbyte = ((RCCENTER_2 >> 8) & 0x00ff);

        //We're done with calibration! Flash the LED a few times to indicate success.
        for(byte caliblink = 0; caliblink < 10; caliblink++) {
          PORTB |= (1 << 5);
          PORTB &= ~(1 << 5);
      } //End of master calibration routine

    } //End of check signal over calibration threshold

  } //End of check signal good



  • The Return of a Legend: ChibiKart Reunion Tour feat. Brushless Rage
  • Operation ENDURING BROWN: The First Battle of Bunk Bed Hill
  • Operation ENDURING BROWN: Well, This Smells Familiar
  • Reassembling a Bridgeport J-head with Uncle Charles! And More About Hooking Up Your Annoyingly Chinese VFD
  • Operation ENDURING BROWN: The Battle for VANTRUCK Rages On
  • Brushless Hipsterism Intensifies: Returning to Brushless Rage. Brushless Mini-Rage!? And Trying Hub Motor Drive in a Beetleweight
  • NERC Sportsman’s Class Reform Notes
  • A Return to Inexpensive Chinese Van Lighting: LED Sealed Beams Update
  • A Different Kind of Chinese Motor Controller?! Adding Dynamic Braking to your Inexpensive Chinese VFD
  • The Emotional Roller Coaster of Vantruck: Attack on the U.S.S. BROWN C.STENNIS, Motorama to Now

    One Response to “The Forthcoming RageBridge: Stick Calibration”

    1. Doug Gallardo Jr Says:

      +1 Internets.